ListsInsuranceALLHIGTRVCINFPGRCB
6 Insurance Stocks to Consider Buying Below 14x Earnings
- Six insurers trade below 14 times trailing earnings while underwriting remains profitable.
- Allstate’s lowest multiple comes with substantial catastrophe exposure.
- Investment gains and reserve releases complicate comparisons across the group.
Insurance stocks below 14 times earnings offer something more useful than low prices alone: profitable underwriting. Allstate (ALL, $267.64, —), Hartford (HIG, $137.48, —), Travelers (TRV, $403.23, —), Cincinnati Financial (CINF, $189.65, —), Progressive (PGR, $235.78, —) and Chubb (CB, $375.74, —) all combine modest multiples with insurance operations that earned more in premiums than they spent on claims and expenses.
That distinction matters when comparing them with other insurance stocks. A combined ratio below 100 signals an underwriting profit, before investment income. But today’s earnings are not necessarily normal earnings: catastrophe claims, reserve adjustments and securities movements can make an apparently inexpensive insurer less straightforward than its headline multiple suggests.
Trailing P/E: Allstate 6.1x, Hartford 8.4x, Travelers 10.6x, Cincinnati Financial 11.2x, Progressive 11.9x, Chubb 13.1x.
Allstate and Hartford merit their valuation discounts
Allstate sells auto and home insurance to US households, alongside protection plans; Property-Liability premiums supply most revenue. Its 6.1x trailing P/E is the lowest here, but its financials need reading through the catastrophe cycle rather than extrapolating a strong earnings base.
Allstate reported an 86.6 combined ratio, leaving considerable underwriting profit despite heavier weather losses. Catastrophe losses reached $1.650 billion against $558 million a year earlier. The attraction is that cushion; the caveat is how quickly storms can consume it. This is inexpensive earnings, not dependable earnings.
Hartford’s core business supplies workers’ compensation, property and liability insurance to US companies. It also sells household cover and employee benefits. At 8.4x trailing earnings, the valuation discounts a business with profitable commercial underwriting rather than one dependent solely on investment returns.
However, Hartford said core earnings were $956 million, down 6% from $1.022 billion a year earlier. Its Business Insurance combined ratio was 91.3. That supports the franchise, but weaker operating earnings explain why the low multiple is not automatically a mispricing.
Travelers offers cleaner evidence than Cincinnati Financial
Travelers sells commercial and personal property-and-casualty policies to businesses, public bodies and households, mainly in the US; those premiums underpin the business. Its 10.6x trailing P/E looks reasonable for an insurer whose underwriting performance provides a substantial earnings foundation.
Travelers reported an 86.8% combined ratio and $1.432 billion of pretax underwriting income. Yet $234 million of favourable prior-year reserve development helped results. The operating strength supports the multiple, although reserve releases are less repeatable than profits on newly written policies.
Cincinnati Financial sells US property-and-casualty cover through independent agents, earning premiums alongside returns from a large equity-and-bond portfolio. Its 11.2x trailing P/E needs particular care: GAAP earnings jump around with that investment book, so operating income is the better lens.
Cincinnati reported operating income of $443 million against $449 million a year earlier, while its combined ratio deteriorated to 90.9 from 88.2. Underwriting remained profitable despite heavier catastrophe claims. That resilience matters, but the accounting volatility makes its apparent discount less persuasive than Travelers’.
Progressive and Chubb justify their higher multiples
Progressive primarily insures personal cars, selling directly and through agents, with commercial auto and a smaller home book. Auto generates the vast majority of premiums. Its 11.9x trailing P/E reflects a focused franchise, though concentration also exposes it to competition in motor insurance.
Progressive reported an 88.7 combined ratio, improved from 89.5 a year earlier. That underwriting discipline supports the valuation. However, the company said growth moderated amid competition and some rate cuts: maintaining margins while attracting policyholders is becoming harder.
Chubb, Zurich-based and US-listed, sells commercial and personal cover across North America and overseas, plus life insurance; P&C supplies most premiums. Its 13.1x trailing P/E is the richest here, but its financials support a quality premium.
Chubb reported an 84.1% P&C combined ratio. Still, $511 million of favourable reserve development helped offset catastrophe losses. Diversification and underwriting profitability justify the relative premium, but reserve support limits how confidently this quarter can be projected forward.
This list suits readers seeking profitable insurers at restrained earnings multiples, with tolerance for weather and accounting volatility. Sustained deterioration in underwriting, weaker pricing or profits increasingly dependent on reserve releases would weaken the case. Conversely, resilient margins without those supports would make the modest valuations more convincing.
Source: Stocklytics data, as of 13 Nov 2026.
This article is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice.