Graham Value Strategy

Benjamin Graham's defensive screen: cheap earnings and assets, a strong current ratio, and a dividend.

How stocks are selected

How rebalancing works

Survivorship: 178 of 225 former index members included (79% of names that left the S&P 500 during this window have usable price history). A delisting is sold at the last price, or at a total loss when a bankruptcy is indicated (92 delisted names in the priced universe). Former members without a matched price history are absent from the backtest.

Backtest

Window
2016-04-01 to 2026-11-06
CAGR
9.0%
Total return
149.4%
Max drawdown
-21.4%
Sharpe
0.80
S&P 500 CAGR
12.7%

S&P 500 comparison over the same period

2016-04-01 to 2026-11-06. Benchmark SPY.

MeasureStrategyS&P 500
CAGR9.0%12.7%
Total return149.4%255.4%
Max drawdown-21.4%-34.1%
Sharpe0.80.76

Yearly returns versus the S&P 500

YearStrategyS&P 500
20169.4%8.0%
20175.2%19.4%
2018-5.2%-6.3%
20192.8%28.8%
202032.2%16.2%
202128.7%27.0%
20223.3%-19.5%
202313.1%24.3%
20244.1%23.3%
20257.3%16.4%
20260.2%7.8%

Rebalance history

The 2026-04-01 rebalance holds 3 of 20. The screen passed fewer names than the target, so the unfilled slots are cash and the filters were not relaxed.

DateHoldingsAddedRemovedStrategy %S&P %
2016-04-017 of 20DD WDC UNM MOS PFG PHM HP—0.0%0.0%
2017-04-033 of 20ASR AFLDD WDC MOS PFG PHM HP+13.0%+13.7%
2018-04-025 of 20PFG BEN—+13.5%+24.4%
2019-04-017 of 20HFC LEN SLG HPAFL BEN+12.1%+38.1%
2020-04-0115 of 20VNO COP TPR PHM ADS HIG BEN DHI FOX NUE FOXAHFC SLG HP-6.2%+19.0%
2021-04-014 of 20KIMVNO COP TPR PHM ADS HIG LEN BEN DHI FOX NUE FOXA+86.2%+93.6%
2022-04-018 of 20DD AIG PHM LEN BEN L GLASR UNM KIM+94.5%+118.9%
2023-04-038 of 20ASR MBC MU BXPPHM L PFG GL+97.9%+98.6%
2024-04-014 of 20BG VICI LDD AIG MBC LEN MU BXP BEN+136.1%+152.3%
2025-04-016 of 20LEN IVZ NUEL+135.2%+171.1%
2026-04-013 of 20—BG IVZ NUE+153.1%+216.7%

Current holdings

The 2026-04-01 rebalance holds 3 of 20. The screen passed fewer names than the target, so the unfilled slots are cash and the filters were not relaxed.

Past performance is not a forecast and this is not financial advice. Each rebalance uses only fundamentals that were already public (filing date, or period end plus 90 days) and the adjusted close on that date. Holdings are equal-weighted, with no transaction costs.

All strategies